IRISHCYCLE.COM
Why is public transport in Mayo mainly used by people with free travel or no other options?
Good public transport frequency on paper can obscure major problems.Comment & Analysis: The combined public transport connections between Mayos largest towns, Ballina and Castlebar, offer reasonably good frequency. So, why is it mainly used by people with free travel or no other options?Its around 35-39km between the two towns, depending on the route, and its about a 35-40 minute drive. The longest direct public transport option has buffer time built in, but even with that, its only scheduled to be 10 minutes longer. In Dublin, nearly all public transport in Zone 1 is covered by the TFI 90 fare that includes from Rush and Lusk to Dun Laoghaire. A distance close enough to 35km without looking at the maximum possible distance in the zone. These are the prices for any combination of public service bus, Luas, and train in the zone within 90 minutes using a Leap card:Adult: 2.00Young Adult/Student: 1.00Child: 0.65Daily and weekly capping also applies when you spend over the caps, all further trips are free: The areas outside of Zone 1 arent as good value, but you can still buy an all zones daily ticket for 16.80 for adults, 8.40 for young adults and students, and 5.50 for children. And those give you unlimited travel within all zones for the day.Meanwhile, the bus tickets I bought this morning to get from Ballina to Castlebar were 36 one-way for myself and two children on the private operator Citylink (route 430).To be clear: I ended up buying it off the driver rather than online, and thats my own fault, but why penalise people like that for off-peak trips on a part of the route that will nearly always have space? The online tickets show up as 31.50 for a single and 50.40 for a return.The train would have been a fraction of that at 10.35 for the three of us. We would have even accepted the extra wait on the 9.35am service for the connecting service, but the train station in Castlebar isnt central, and its too far away from where we needed to be at 11am. So it wasnt an option today.The return by train is just over 20 online, and the family day return (including another adult) from the ticket machine is 19.50, so even better value.Where there is a timely connection, rail is both good value and reasonably fast, if the station isnt too far from your destination, and theres also the issue of some very long waits for some of the return options.In some cases, the Ballina shuttle train could leave Manulla Junction, go to Castlebar, and return without interfering with mainline services, but there really isnt a focus on making rail trips within Mayo attractive. That should change and would not cost much more to run the service. Theres also Route 52, Bus ireanns Expressway route, which is the State-owned public transport companys fully commercial run route. It does not get public money. Their onlineprice is slightly cheaper than Citylink, but none suited us this morning.Bus ireann claims (and Im not really surprised) that the Expressway service to Galway via Castlebar isnt commercially viable, and its apparently to be replaced by a public service obligation route (a route funded and more closely controlled by the National Transport Authority).There are two other bus routes connecting the two towns. Route 420, which is the current direct public service obligation route that only runs three times a day from Ballina to Castlebar, and the Ballina to Castlebar Local Link service, which is very indirect via Crossmolina and is scheduled to take 1.5 hours at the best of timesThe fare finder on Bus ireanns website shows paying for singles on Leap seems to be the cheapest way Leap Child Single is 3.36, and Leap Adult Single is 6.72. The return amounts to just under 27 for the three of us.Bus ireanns fare finder nearly makes the TFI Live app look good, nearly. But on a phone, it took me somewhere between five and ten minutes to find the following fare matrix for the Local Link service basically, itd be 20 return for the three of us. Much better value but a huge time penalty, and none of the three departures per day suited us.Besides the price, you have to look up different websites for the timelines too. The much-hated TFI Live app and website service has yet to be improved, and when I looked it up, it showed the Citylink service we used listed a departure time 10 minutes later than the time listed on the operators website. The Citylink website lists it as departing 10 minutes earlier, and Im nearly sure it departed just after 10.00am.IMAGE: Public transport apps often love to exaggerate the walking time from their stops to the centre of towns, etc, when it would be better to leave walking time up to individuals, depending not just on their speed, but where they are going and how they are getting there. So, while theres reasonably good frequency between the two towns, its split between four different services with four websites and fares, and 2-3 different departure points.The replacement bus for the Expressway could address many of these issues; others will require more systematic changes at the national level, including a single fare system (which has no national delivery timeline). I just hope the existence of the private Citylink service or the indirect services isnt used as a reason to implement a proper public service between Ballina and Galway via Castlebar. In the meantime, isnt it any wonder that public transport in most places outside our cities is mainly for students, people with free travel, and others with no access to a car?
0 Σχόλια
0 Μοιράστηκε
331 Views